
| “I’m Always Smiling” Billy Hays And His Orchestra; Irving Kaufman, vocal February 15, 1928 (OKeh 40996 mx 400085) |
| “My Miami Moon” Billy Hays And His Orchestra; Irving Kaufman, vocal February 15, 1928 (OKeh 40996 mx 400084) |
Billy Hays was a well-known composer who led a Philadelphia-based band that became popular in the mid-1920s through radio broadcasts and was regularly featured at prominent local Chinese restaurants offering dining and dancing.
From the Edward Mitchell collection, here are two out of a total of four recordings made by OKeh between December 1927 and August 1928 that were credited on the label to Billy Hays and His Orchestra but which were actually recorded by Sam Lanin’s band. A fifth recording from this period credited to Hays was recorded by Harry Reser’s band.
The actual Billy Hays band did record four sides for OKeh in October 1928 and January 1929, which were credited on the label as Billy Hays’ Cathay Orchestra. Subsequently, the band recorded ten sides for Victor issued under the band’s own name. In 1931, the band also recorded some sides for the American Record Corporation, which were issued on the company’s various dime-store labels and credited to the band. However, some sources suggest that some or all of these releases were actually remakes recorded by other bands but credited to Hays’ orchestra.
What all of the OKeh recordings by the Sam Lanin and Harry Reser bands credited to the Billy Hays band have in common is that they are of songs for which Billy Hays was either composer or lyricist.
Hays wrote the lyrics for “I’m Always Smiling,” which was composed by Joe Darcy and Lou Herscher, who, like Hays, was also from Philadelphia.
This version of the song will join a recording by the Colonial Club Orchestra, which is already in Radio Dismuke’s playlist.
For “My Miami Moon,” Hays and Herscher supplied the music. The lyrics were selected through a special Philadelphia Daily News contest that attracted more than 3,000 submissions from the public. The winner was Katherine Wexler. Arrangements had already been made in advance for the song to be published, and Ms. Wexler became eligible for a share of its royalty earnings.
I have not been able to find any information explaining why OKeh initially used other bands for records issued under Hays’ name rather than recording the actual Hays orchestra, as it eventually began doing in October 1928.
If I were to venture a guess, logistics and economics may have played a role. Then, as now, live performances, not records, were the primary source of most musicians’ income. For a regional band to make a recording for OKeh meant either traveling to its New York City recording studios or waiting for the company to make a field trip with its portable recording equipment to a city within reasonable travel distance.
OKeh did make a field trip to Philadelphia in March 1927, but apparently none were made after that date.
Travel by automobile between Philadelphia and New York City in 1928 took approximately four to six hours each way – which would have made for either a very grueling, lengthy day or an overnight stay. Either way would have been incompatible with an evening gig in the Philadelphia area.
The same trip could have been made by an express train in about two hours each way. Factoring in travel between the station and the recording studio, along with the length of the recording session itself, a round trip might still have been compatible with an evening engagement in Philadelphia. But tickets for around a dozen musicians would have been a not-insignificant expense that would have had to have been picked up either by OKeh or the band.
The February 15, 1928 recording session these two sides are from coincides with the approximate time period that Katherine Wexler’s lyrics for “My Miami Moon” were selected as the winner of the Philadelphia Daily News contest.
Given Hays’ popularity in the Philadelphia and Southern New Jersey region and the massive publicity that the Philadelphia Daily News undoubtedly gave to its own lyrics contest, issuing the record under Billy Hays’ name would have helped sales in that region. It also would have expanded Hays’ name recognition beyond his home market.
The website linked above quotes a 1964 Record Research article by Jack Montez, who wrote:
I have heard MARIANETTE, MY MIAMI MOON, and SWEETHEART LANE, and they certainly have all the ear marks [sic] of the group that Billy had at the Cathay Tea Garden, and later on at the Golden Dragon in Philadelphia, and I knew that band pretty well. The above tunes were Hays or sidemen compositions, and Billy’s voice is unmistakable.
Montez was definitely mistaken in his recollection of Hays’s voice on “My Miami Moon.” The vocalist is clearly Irving Kaufman, who is also credited in the DAHR. (On British Parlophone pressings of both sides, Kaufman’s vocals were credited under the pseudonym Noel Taylor.)
You can hear Hays’ voice on this recording via YouTube from one of the later OKeh recording sessions that used the actual Hays band.
However, it is entirely conceivable that the Sam Lanin Orchestra was playing from the same arrangements used by the Hays band, in which case, it would have sounded similar.

(From The Billboard, February 11, 1928)













